How the Indira Canteen is a Failure and a Success

Indira Canteen is a fast food joint that has been touted as CM Siddaramaiah's pet project in the city of Bengaluru, Karnataka. The canteen aims to serve 500 people per meal per day. Rahul Gandhi inaugurated this populist scheme of the Congress led Karnataka Government on Independence Day 2017. This was done in run up to the Karnataka Assembly Elections that is taking place five days from today. All 197 wards have their own Indira Canteen, built at a cost of approximately INR 30 lakhs each {1}.
The setting up of this canteen is obviously to reduce hunger among the poor. Indira Canteen serves food at heavily subsidized rates by the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike. Breakfast can be availed at Rs. 5 and lunch at Rs. 10.

The entire scheme has been well thought of and according to reports has been running smoothly{2}. The canteens are still operational (this is itself a major win for the Government), food is being cooked at remote locations by companies to whom this job has been tendered out to and every day the canteen sells all the prepared items on time.

Source

While I am glad that the Government has been able to successfully implement this scheme in a short period of time, a few things need to be questioned.
This canteen has obviously been constituted to serve people who cannot afford three meals a day. However, there is no restriction on who can avail subsidized meals at canteen locations. A minimum wage earner who struggles to feed himself and his family should obviously be served meals at the canteen. If he makes it in time and joins the queue early enough, he will be fed. Otherwise if 500 people beat him to buying food, he has to go hungry that day. When a scheme like this is implemented in which good food that fills an appetite is served at dirt cheap prices, relatively richer people such as auto-rickshaw drivers, car-drivers, plumbers, servicemen who can afford to eat elsewhere chose to eat in the Indira Canteen instead of paying a slight premium elsewhere. They are not to blame. The CM said that through Indira Canteens poor people would be able to afford food. However, putting a cap of just 500 meals per canteen is not justified when the aim is to feed all and eradicate hunger. It is not known by many people who do not use this service that there is a cap on the number of meals served. On the face of it, this project is commendable and worthy of everyone's praise. But it is not.

The population of Bengaluru is 1.23 crores {3}. For ease of calculation assume that people are equally divided among the 197 wards. That comes to around 60,000 people per ward. Indira Canteens only serves around 0.83% of the people in each ward due to the 500 meals restriction. A 2016 report states that India has a population in which around 30% of the people are living Below the Poverty Line (BPL) {4). A 2017 report says that the urban population living BPL is around 35% {5}. According to our calculation that amounts to 21,000 people are living BPL in each ward. Assuming that a rule is instated that only BPL people can use the canteen, they can still serve just 2.3% of the 21,000 people per ward. Yes, in a real life scenario, all 1.23 crore people are not equally divided among all wards. That actually worsens the whole thing. In population dense areas, a lower percentage of the already low percentage of people will be able to get affordable food.

At the beginning of this article, I said that the Government's train of thought is questionable. Did the Government create this project to satisfy the hunger of individuals who are poor? Did the Government realise that this project will be beneficial to only a small number of lucky people who reach early enough to have food? Did the Government think it through in terms of who can and who cannot avail these services? Did the Government, sitting in their air conditioned rooms, traveling in SUV's 'gifted' to them by industrialists and living a luxurious life in their humongous bungalows realise that there is a huge number of people who can benefit from these canteens, if not for the excessive subsidy that scants the number of people who it can benefit?

I'll let you answer these question on 12th May, 2018 when you go to vote and make your choice!

Comments

The Great Omani Coastal Route

Route 15 : Muscat-Nizwa The parents, seemingly forever, had been planning a trip to Oman. Why Oman? Well, that’s a question I asked myself too. My dad, in the 90s, spent close to a decade in the UAE but barring a work trip, had never visited Oman. Fast forward to the 21 st century, countless Oman Air flights from India to Europe later, he found himself stranded in Muscat. A ‘technical difficulty’ they said. He visited the Sultan Qaboos Mosque but didn’t get to see much more – it was only a 24-hour layover. However, the constant propaganda he was subjected to via the in-flight entertainment, and the cabin crew he made conversation with, convinced him that the country has a lot to offer. A friend from the UAE, who spoke highly of Oman, apparently also played a role. The parents had their mind set on Oman. The stars aligned and clubbing together a bunch of bank holidays in India, they decided on visiting in April. Unfortunately, or fortunately (the jury is still out), ...

Life during the COVID-19 lockdown

The past three weeks have impacted people around India in different ways. The migrant labourers and daily wage workers have unarguably been affected the worst. It has been an interesting three weeks in which the concept of privilege was spoken about vastly in the media. Even though the salaried middle class is also affected, their lives have been phenomenally better than, for example, those they employ to clean their houses or wash their dishes. It is at times such as these that I realise how lucky a majority of my friends and I are. While most of the country is suffering (suffering in the real sense of not being able to afford and procure three square meals a day and NOT because a shop ran out of imported cheese) in lockdown, my parents could work from home, without intruding into each other’s personal space and could carry out some, if not most of their work from the comfort of their house, unlike the majority of the country. I have been reading articles about the shortfalls of in...

Beating the winter blues - Morocco

After having spent just over two months in England, with short trips to America’s east coast on work and Paris for Diwali, I was itching to travel somewhere new – somewhere I hadn’t been before. I found myself in one of the study rooms at university, unable to focus on my readings. Winter was setting in. The days were getting shorter, London was getting greyer, and the sun had gone into hibernation. An important question was running in my mind – one that would determine how I would overcome the impending winter blues – what will I do during the Christmas break? A typical international student’s response would be simple – book a return ticket to your home country. However, as a seasoned international student, my response had to be different, right? With a not-so-powerful passport in hand, I grappled with my options. Limited by choices of visa-regime friendly choices, I first laid out a bunch of criteria for an anti-winter blues holiday of choice. I wanted three thing...

Yulu Miracle - app based electric scooters

Those of you who live in Bangalore, especially in places such as Indiranagar, Koramangala and Whitefield may have noticed different looking and noiseless blue scooters whizzing past you as you are stuck in traffic. These new scooters that can be hired through a mobile app called Yulu are used by all age groups. Currently, a majority of people (including me) use it for joyrides rather than optimizing their travel. For those of you who still have no idea, refer to the picture above! These electric scooters that are provided by Yulu are known as 'Miracles' and can be hired per 10 minutes through their app that can be downloaded on the Play Store as well as the App Store . Having clocked at least 15 hours on these exciting new scooters in the past few weeks, I have many stories to tell. Although there is more awareness about these scooters today, as close as three weeks ago, barely anyone had any idea about it. Riding these scooters were fun and the closest I coul...

The Actual Effectiveness of the Cap on Movie Ticket Pricing in Karnataka

Source: Google The Karnataka Government, announced in its budget in March 2017 that it would be capping the price of movie tickets at Rs. 200+Taxes+Internet Handling Fees (if any). This decision taken by the Government was lauded by many. While this decision was originally lauded as a good one, here is what one must consider before commending it further. The Rs. 200 cap excludes all Gold Screen/Seat Tickets. All Kannada films is priced at a maximum of approximately Rs. 233 (all inclusive*), but tickets for non - kannada films are at a maximum of Rs. 300 (all inclusive). {1} While the Budget announcement by Chief Minister, Siddaramaiah sounds ideal, by reading the above facts we can gather that the actual price of tickets for Non-Kannada movies will not be much lesser than what it was prior to the 2017 Budget. This brings me to my next question. Should this budgeta ry decision be lauded as much as it is being done today? Siddaramaiah Source: Google Considering that m...

Opinion on the Tax Rebate - Budget 2019

Source The Union Budget of India that was presented on Feb 1, 2019 was a populist-vote bank driven one filled with proposals to woo all possible stakeholders who are eligible to vote. Be it farmers, the middle class or the economically stronger ones, all sections of society after a brief glance at the highlights of the budget will be content with what Piyush Goyal has to offer in the sixth and final Budget of this term of the NDA. Although I found many parts of the budget a questionable waste of money to fuel populist schemes, I did enjoy certain parts of it, especially the newly introduced tax rebate. The proposed tax rebate in which income upto INR 5 lakhs is essentially tax-free is one that I wholly welcome for many reasons. The tax-rebate proposal and terms is something that I welcome unconditionally but the way how the Finance Minister has portrayed income up to INR 6.5 lakhs tax free (with the disclaimer that this is only possible if all the 'right' investments ar...

Investment Advice #1 - Direct Equity - is it really for you?

Depending on who is reading this article, you may or may not know that I have been investing my money since 2015 when I was just 13 years old. The concept of money growing in value by doing minimum or no work at all intrigued me and led me to learning about the various ways to invest money. Having been in this business for the last four years, I will try and 'advise' you in a way that will convince you to invest in the right way. This article is not going to advise you to invest a certain portion of your income or invest in a stock(s) or anything else that you will probably be able to read elsewhere online. Instead, this article, and the ones to follow will give you my learning experiences that I think may help a new investor. You may or may not agree either because you are in denial of reality or you may not have faced a particular challenge but I recommend that you give these tips a read and let me know what you think! Tip #1 Direct Equity - is it really for you? Most o...

Sanjith Rao

Search This Blog